我們是否應當接受通過基因增強構建道德上更為完善的人類？

Should We Accept the Creation of Morally Superior Human Beings Through Genetic Enhancement?

Abstract

LANGUAGE NOTE | Document text in Chinese; abstract in English.

This commentary discusses the prospect of genetic moral enhancement, focusing on the moderate Genetic Virtue Project (GVP) articulated in “Can We Biotechnologically Construct a Morally Better Human?” While the GVP aims only to strengthen an individual’s natural receptivity to virtue acquisition, this commentary argues that from both legal and policy perspectives, this approach remains fundamentally problematic. Theoretically, it creates an irreconcilable conflict between parental reproductive autonomy and the future autonomy of the embryo, as irreversible genetic alterations preemptively undermine the very basis for an individual’s self- determination. Practically, its implementation is infeasible due to the legal principle of technological neutrality and the impossibility of legally establishing unified moral content. As modulating moral emotions cannot guarantee morally right action or motivation, the path to moral improvement must involve enhancing traditional moral education and social design rather than pursuing biotechnological shortcuts.