Engelhardt on the Family


  • 李翰林 (Hon Lam LI) 香港中文大學 (The Chinese University of Hong Kong, HONG KONG)




LANGUAGE NOTE | Document text in English

Tristram Engelhardt, Jr. offers erudite and compelling arguments for the view that all families should try to realize the traditional family. Although I tend to agree with him from a personal standpoint, I doubt that this view can be justified to those with whom we are in reasonable disagreement about the family. I make three critical points. First, although Engelhardt stops short of saying that the state should encourage people to form traditional families, or discourage those who do not, some state perfectionists might do so. From the perspective of public reason, it is unjust for the state to favor some conceptions of what is good over others, if these conceptions are all reasonable. Moreover, those whose conceptions of the good are not favored will feel that they are disrespected. Second, insofar as Engelhardt thinks that all families should try to realize traditional families, the traditional family would not be perceived as good by those who do not like children. Moreover, it would be difficult to persuade those who have decided not to have children for reasons of career, burden, or more altruistic concerns. Third, against Engelhardt’s stance against the “egalitarian aspirations” of liberalism, I argue that women too often sacrifice their possible careers for the sake of the family, even when they hold advanced degrees from prestigious universities, or professional qualifications. This kind of injustice is too uncomfortable to ignore.

DOWNLOAD HISTORY | This article has been downloaded 29 times in Digital Commons before migrating into this platform.


Download data is not yet available.




How to Cite

LI, H. L. (2013). Engelhardt on the Family. International Journal of Chinese &Amp; Comparative Philosophy of Medicine, 11(2), 153–160. https://doi.org/10.24112/ijccpm.111551